You’re Too Pretty to Have MS

Just because you can’t see an illness, doesn’t mean it’s not there.

A chiropractor once told me I was too pretty to have multiple sclerosis. His hands were still on my shoulders, like the observation itself was a form of treatment—as if enough conviction could argue my nervous system back into line. He wasn’t trying to fix my spine. He was trying to fix the story, so it would make sense to him. Pretty women don’t get sick. Sick women don’t get to be pretty. Pick one.

My own neurologist has said some version of the same line, though it lands completely differently coming from him. Not because he means it more gently, but because I know exactly who’s saying it. He’s the sweetest man in the world, yes, but he’s also spent years with his hands actually in the research, chasing the cause, and not just managing the symptoms. He’s been doing the unglamorous work of trying to find something closer to a cure. When even he does the double take, I understand it’s not doubt. It’s the same collision everyone has: The data in front of him says one thing, and my face says another, and for a half-second the two don’t reconcile. He catches himself faster than most. But he catches himself.

Then there are the strangers, and strangers in Brooklyn don’t do delicate. “What’s wrong with you?” I have been asked flat out, on the street, at a party, in a waiting room, the way you’d ask someone what train they take. Not cruel. Just Brooklyn. Nobody here has ever been trained in euphemism. But underneath the bluntness sits the same assumption as the chiropractor’s hands on my shoulders: that sickness has a look, and I don’t have it, so whatever’s wrong with me must be smaller than what I’m claiming.

Here’s what nobody says out loud: that sentence—“you’re too pretty to have MS”—was never actually about only my face. It’s also about their comfort—what to say after hearing “what’s wrong with me.” If I look well, they don’t have to reckon with a version of illness that doesn’t announce itself. Multiple sclerosis doesn’t come with a uniform. It comes for the nerve endings, the signal between brain and body, and it can do that while you still know how to blend a cream blush.

That contradiction—not my appearance, but their need for illness to be legible—is the actual subject here. Invisible illness doesn’t mean invisible to your face. It means invisible to your credibility.

I understand the confusion, honestly, because I spent my whole life before diagnosis working the exact border they’re confused by. I ran the front desk of a medical aesthetician’s office— where skincare, fashion, and healing all lived under one roof—for a woman who took her work as seriously as any surgeon. She used to tell me, “Always look your best, no matter what’s going on.”

At the time, I heard that as a rule about professionalism. It took another 20 years and a diagnosis for me to understand it as something closer to a philosophy; that falling apart and holding it together were never opposites. They were something you did at the same time, with the same hands.

I also managed a fashion showroom and attended the fashion shows at Bryant Park during New York Fashion Week. I’m a Brooklyn-born oil painter with more gallery shows than I can list cleanly. Beauty wasn’t a hobby for me, or a mask I picked up later—it was a trade, a language I was fluent in long before I ever needed it as armor.

It goes back further than that, actually, to a teenage summer, standing in my best friend’s kitchen—we’re still close, 30-some years later—when her mother came down the stairs in a genie costume. Sequins, sheer balloon pants, fully committed, on her way to nowhere that had anything to do with Halloween. She walked past me and said, like she was handing me something important, “Always keep them coming home, Valerie.”

I was maybe 18. I filed it under vanity advice, the kind you roll your eyes at and remember anyway. It took me decades to understand that she wasn’t talking about a husband at all. She was talking about staying present in your own life—about not disappearing from the room, whatever the room requires of you. Both/and, before I had the words for it: You can be the woman in sequins on the stairs and the woman who’s tired, who’s scared, who’s holding something together where nobody can see.

I was diagnosed with MS 13 years ago, at 50. Last year, at 62, I broke my ankle—MS complicating every part of the recovery—and spent five months in a rehab facility. I wrote the bulk of my memoir from that place: propped up, unable to walk, dictating pages between physical therapy sessions.

And through all five months, I kept my skincare routine, the full multi-step version, not the abbreviated one. I kept my four-step hair-washing ritual, too. My hairstylist came to the rehab facility to color my hair, because gray roots were not going to be the thing that broke me that year. The nursing aides understood, without my having to explain it twice, that I needed to be dressed, not just clothed. Put together, not just covered.

It wasn’t denial. It wasn’t vanity dressed up as resilience. On the days I couldn’t stand at the parallel bars, when my leg simply would not answer the instruction my brain was sending it, a blowout didn’t fix that. Purple polish didn’t get me one inch closer to walking. But it did something else, something I don’t think our culture has a good vocabulary for: It kept me recognizable to myself.

When everything else about my body had become unfamiliar—untrustworthy, unpredictable, negotiating with me instead of obeying me—the ritual of doing my own face in a mirror was one of the only places I still got to author something. Beauty, for a chronically ill woman, isn’t the opposite of the illness. Sometimes it’s the last room in the house you still control.

To the chiropractor, my doctor, and every stranger who’s ever asked me what’s wrong with me on a Brooklyn sidewalk: Stop reading perfect curls as proof that everything is fine. Stop treating polish as an alibi. The women who look “too well” to be sick are not lying to you. We’re the ones doing two full-time jobs at once, managing a disease you can’t see, and refusing to let it erase the parts of us you can. That’s not deception. That’s just what it costs to stay yourself while your body negotiates a war nobody else is invited to watch.

Want our stories delivered to you? Sign up for our newsletter, then follow us on Instagram, Threads, and Facebook for regular updates and a lot of other silliness. And if you’ve liked what you’ve read and want to help us keep bringing stories your way, please consider a small donation.